Game Save Lab

Which guild to join in Gothic II: militia, monastery or mercenaries

Checked against Gothic II: Gold Edition 2.6 · November 16, 2026

In Gothic II you join one of three guilds in chapter 1: the city militia (later Paladin), the monastery (Novice, then Fire Mage) or Onar’s mercenaries (later Dragon Hunter). The choice is final and decides your armour, your teachers and whether you ever cast a magic circle. This guide gives the exact joining conditions, the deadline, the promotions and what each guild can learn, for Night of the Raven and for Classic. The promotion section mentions chapter 3 story events.

The three paths at a glance

  • Militia → Paladin: join with Lord Andre in the barracks of the harbour district, become a Paladin with Lord Hagen in chapter 3. A fighter’s path with paladin runes but no magic circles.
  • Novice → Fire Mage: join with Pedro at the monastery gate, become a Fire Mage with Pyrokar after the Test of Fire, still in chapter 1. The only guild that learns the six circles of magic.
  • Mercenary → Dragon Hunter: join with Lee on Onar’s farm, become a Dragon Hunter in chapter 3. A fighter’s path with the most generous trainers for strength and two-handed weapons.

Joining pays 400 experience for the militia, the mercenaries and the step to Fire Mage, and 250 for becoming a novice. Each joining dialogue is open only to a guildless hero, so the first guild you join closes the other two for good.

The deadline: chapter 2 needs a guild

There is no timer. The limit is the story: chapter 2 starts only when Lord Hagen sends you to the Valley of Mines, and the paladin guarding his hall lets in only militiamen, Fire Mages and mercenaries. A guildless hero or a mere novice cannot get to him, so all the joining happens in chapter 1.

In Night of the Raven Hagen also checks it himself and refuses to send a hero without a proper guild. In Classic the guard at his door does the same job.

A novice has to finish the Test of Fire and become a Fire Mage before chapter 2 can start. Plan for it if you choose the monastery.

Joining the militia

Ask Lord Andre to join. He takes only citizens, and there are two ways around that rule, plus a third in Night of the Raven:

  • Citizenship: become the apprentice of Harad (smith), Bosper (bowyer) or Constantino (alchemist). A master takes you once at least four of the five masters of the lower town (Harad, Thorben, Bosper, Constantino, Matteo) vouch for you, see the first hours.
  • The thieves’ guild: Andre asks you to find and destroy it. It counts only once Cassia, Jesper and Ramirez are all dead; just telling Andre where they hide does not. He pays 300 gold and 500 experience on top.
  • Night of the Raven: Martin’s letter of recommendation, see the Ring of Water section below.

You get the Light Militia Armor and 400 experience. Andre then sends you to find Peck for your weapon and gives you missions of his own, and from now on the upper quarter and Hagen’s hall are open.

Becoming a novice, then a Fire Mage

  1. At the monastery gate ask Pedro how to get in and about the rules. He wants 1,000 gold and a sheep.
  2. Buy the sheep Betsy from the shepherd Pepe on Onar’s farm for 100 gold (Onar sells one for 200 if Pepe is dead). Walk her to the gate with 1,000 gold in your pocket and tell Pedro you want to become a novice. You get the Novice’s Robe and 250 experience.
  3. Inside, read about the Test of Fire in the monastery’s books: every novice may demand it. Ask Pyrokar about the paladins first, then demand the trial.
  4. Pyrokar’s task: follow the signs of Innos and bring what lies at the end of the path. He gives you a key; the reward at the end is a blank runestone. Three other novices, Agon, Igaraz and Ulf, are on the same trail.
  5. Ulthar’s task: make a Fire Arrow rune. Hyglas teaches it for this test if you bring him the ingredients.
  6. Serpentes’ task: find and defeat a summoned living rock, a golem that ordinary weapons and spells cannot harm. The Sacred Hammer, guarded by the novice Garwig in the monastery, is the answer; Serpentes takes it back when you report. Do not kill Garwig: Serpentes turns on you if he is dead.
  7. With all three done, ask Pyrokar to be accepted and take the oath: the Fire Mage’s Robe and 400 experience.

Joining the mercenaries

  1. Tell Lee on Onar’s farm that you want to join. He needs the mercenaries’ votes and then Onar’s approval.
  2. Torlof sets the test: collect Sekob’s rent, or drive the militia off Bengar’s farm. The Bengar job earns more respect (5 points against 3), and Torlof adds his own vote.
  3. Win the rest of the votes: small favours for single mercenaries, and fair duels (challenge first, never kill). Cord votes for you once you are a fighter (30 %) with one- or two-handed weapons, and three won duels count extra. Torlof tells you how your standing is; you need 9 points.
  4. Lee sends you to Onar, who gives his approval, then back to Lee: the Light Mercenary Armor and 400 experience.

Do both of Torlof’s jobs if you can. Lee offers the Medium Mercenary Armor only to a mercenary who did both, and only if you ask him for better armour during chapter 2.

Night of the Raven: the Ring of Water’s help

Once Vatras sends you to Lares, Lares offers to ease your way into one guild, and only one:

  • Militia: guard the crates of Martin, the paladins’ quartermaster at the harbour, at night and catch the thief. Martin’s letter of recommendation lets Andre take you without citizenship.
  • Mercenaries: Cord asks you to find out what happened to Patrick, through the bandit leader Dexter. Once that is done, Cord completes Torlof’s test for you, worth 4 points.
  • Monastery: Daron, the Fire Mage at the city market, lost a statuette of Innos to goblins. Bring it to Pedro (before chapter 3) and he lets you in as a novice without the sheep and the 1,000 gold.

Classic has no Ring of Water, so there only the regular ways above apply.

The second step: Paladin and Dragon Hunter

Spoilers for chapter 3: Bennet, the mercenaries’ smith, is arrested and must be cleared.

  • Paladin: a militiaman asks Lord Hagen to join the order. Hagen agrees only once Bennet has been freed, which happens in chapter 3. You get the Knight’s Armor and a Paladin’s Two-Hander if your two-handed skill is at least your one-handed, otherwise a Paladin’s Sword.
  • Dragon Hunter: a mercenary becomes one automatically when Bennet thanks you after his release, and Bennet then hands you the Light Dragon Hunter’s Armor.
  • Fire Mage: no further rank, but Pyrokar gives a Fire Mage the Heavy Fire Robe after the Eye of Innos is restored at the end of chapter 3.

Armour by guild

Weapon protection in Night of the Raven, with Classic in brackets:

  • Militia: Light Militia Armor 40 (40), on joining. Heavy Militia Armor 70 (60), 2,500 gold from Engor in the castle in the Valley of Mines.
  • Paladin: Knight’s Armor 100 (80), on promotion. Paladin’s Armor 150 (100), in chapter 5 in a hidden room a paladin reaches with a special teleport rune.
  • Monastery: Novice’s Robe 25 (25). Fire Mage’s Robe 40 (40), on the oath. Heavy Fire Robe 100 (80), from Pyrokar at the end of chapter 3.
  • Mercenary: Light Mercenary Armor 30 (30), on joining. Medium Mercenary Armor 50 (45), 500 gold from Lee in chapter 2. Heavy Mercenary Armor 80 (60), 1,000 gold from Lee in chapter 3.
  • Dragon Hunter: Light Dragon Hunter’s Armor 100 (70), Bennet’s gift. Medium 120 (80) for 12,000 gold, from Bennet once you have brought him 20 dragon scales, or from Jan in the castle, who also wants 20 scales first. Heavy 150 (90) for 20,000 gold from Bennet in chapter 5, after you have learned how to coat the scales with ore.

Night of the Raven made guild armour much stronger; some sellers’ offers in the dialogue still quote the older, lower figures. Anyone who frees Gorn in the Valley of Mines in chapter 2 gets a Medium Mercenary Armor from him, whatever the guild.

Trainers and magic by guild

Many teachers serve anyone, but these are tied to a guild. Maximums are Night of the Raven’s, with Classic in brackets:

  • Militia and Paladin: Mortis teaches strength to 60 (60), militia and paladins only. Ruga teaches the crossbow to 90 (60) and dexterity to 60 (60) to militia, paladins and Fire Mages. Wulfgar teaches one- and two-handed to 75 (60) to the militia and to anyone who is not a mercenary or Dragon Hunter. A paladin with 90 % two-handed can finish it to 100 % with Lord Hagen.
  • Paladin magic: Albrecht teaches mana to 90 (100) and hands out paladin runes: Holy Light for free, then for 5 learning points each Small Healing and Holy Arrow once the Eye of Innos is restored, and Medium Healing and Banish Evil in chapter 5 (in Classic they are called Lesser Healing and Harm Evil). Neoras in the monastery teaches alchemy to paladins and Fire Mages, and Parlan and Pyrokar teach paladins mana as well.
  • Fire Mage: the circles of magic with Parlan (1 to 3), Karras (4 and 5) and Pyrokar (6). Circle 2 waits for chapter 2, circle 3 for chapter 3, circle 4 for the restored Eye of Innos, circle 5 for chapter 5, and circle 6 also for knowing the way to Irdorath. Milten in the Valley of Mines teaches the 2nd circle (in Classic also the 1st), and in Night of the Raven Saturas in Jharkendar teaches a Fire Mage circles 2 to 5 on the same schedule once you have asked him about them.
  • Fire Mage runes and mana: Hyglas (fire), Marduk (ice and lightning), Karras (summoning), Parlan (light, healing and more), Pyrokar (the 6th circle spells). Mana: Parlan to 90 (100), then Pyrokar to 300 (250). Babo teaches a mage two-handed to 75 (70).
  • Mercenary and Dragon Hunter: Torlof teaches strength to 200 (90) and dexterity to 90 (90) to the guildless and to mercenaries. Cord teaches one- and two-handed to 90, Wolf the bow to 90. From chapter 4 Lee teaches two-handed to 100 % once you have 75 %, free for mercenaries and Dragon Hunters (others pay 1,000 gold); in Classic he wants 60 % and 1,000 gold from everyone. Wulfgar and Ruga turn mercenaries away.

In Classic a Fire Mage also pays double for weapon training, and novices and mages pay 2 learning points per point of strength or dexterity but only 1 per point of mana, the reverse of everyone else. Night of the Raven dropped those rules: there the cost depends only on how high the value already is. See the learning-points guide for the full costs and runes and magic circles for every spell.

Which one to choose

  • You want to cast real magic: the monastery is the only way to the circles. It costs 1,100 gold up front and the Test of Fire, and in Classic weapons and strength cost a mage double.
  • You want a heavy fighter with the best two-handed teachers: the mercenaries. Torlof teaches strength as far as anyone in the game, and Lee finishes two-handed in chapter 4.
  • You want a fighter with some holy magic, a crossbow and the city’s favour: the militia. Paladin runes heal and strike without needing any circle, and the Paladin’s Armor is among the strongest armour in the game.
  • Cheapest start: the mercenaries need no gold and no citizenship. The militia needs four masters’ votes or the thieves’ guild cleared, the monastery 1,100 gold.

Save in a separate slot before you speak the joining line, so you can try another guild without replaying chapter 1. For schedules of the people involved see where everyone is.

The Guild field in the editor

The save editor shows the hero’s guild on the Character tab, in the Gold and guild card. Changing it changes which guild the game counts him in, so guild-only dialogues and teachers react to it. It does not hand out the armour, the experience or the story steps of joining, and dialogues that already happened stay done.

Use it to repair a broken joining, not as a shortcut: a hero listed in a guild the story never saw him join can find quests and teachers in odd states. Offline single-player only, and copy the savegame folder first, as edits are at your own risk.

Sources