Game Save Lab

Smithing in Gothic II: every weapon you can forge, its teachers and costs

Checked against Gothic II: Gold Edition 2.6 · November 16, 2026

Smithing lets the hero forge his own swords: a plain blade from Raw Steel, magic ore weapons from Lumps of Ore and, at the top, two Dragon Slayers quenched in dragon blood. This guide covers how to learn the craft at all, every weapon with its materials, learning points, damage and strength requirement in Night of the Raven and Classic, who teaches what and to which guild, and Harad’s four extra blades in Night of the Raven. Later chapters are marked as spoilers.

How forging works

You forge at a smithy: heat a piece of Raw Steel in the forge and finish it on the anvil, where you choose the weapon. Every weapon uses one piece of Raw Steel; ore weapons also use Lumps of Ore, and the Dragon Slayers five flasks of Dragon Blood. If materials are missing, you get the steel back.

Every recipe needs the basic lesson first: learning to forge a plain sword. Teachers want learning points, and only Bennet asks for gold for that first lesson. In Night of the Raven the cost depends on the weapon; in Classic every lesson costs 5 learning points.

Raw Steel is cheap: Bennet, Brian, Hakon, Matteo, Khaled, Jora and Engor sell it, and in Night of the Raven Huno, Erol and Garett too. Lumps of Ore come from Bennet, Harad and Khaled, and in Night of the Raven from Huno and Martin, a few per chapter; each is worth 200 gold.

Learning to forge at all

The basic lesson teaches a plain one-handed sword (Sword in Night of the Raven, Self-forged Sword in Classic). It costs 2 learning points in Night of the Raven and 5 in Classic, and three smiths teach it:

  • Harad, the smith in Khorinis’ lower town, teaches only his own apprentice. The apprenticeship needs the approval of at least four of the five masters of the lower town.
  • Bennet, the smith on Onar’s farm, teaches anyone who pays him 30 gold first, whatever their guild.
  • Jan, a dragon hunter in the castle in the Valley of Mines in chapter 4, once you have helped him get the forge there.

Bennet’s 30 gold is the quickest route for a newcomer; Harad is worth it if you plan to be his apprentice anyway, especially in Night of the Raven, where only he teaches the four extra blades.

Plain swords: Sword (Night of the Raven) 40 damage, 30 strength, +5% one-handed skill while held. Self-forged Sword (Classic) 30 damage, 20 strength.

The ore weapons

Eight ore weapons, in pairs of one-hander and two-hander. Night of the Raven numbers first, then Classic. In Night of the Raven each one also raises the matching one- or two-handed skill by 10% while it is equipped:

  • Ore Longsword: 1 Lump of Ore, 4 learning points (Classic 5). 60 damage, 40 strength. Classic: 45 damage, 40 strength.
  • Ore Two-Hander: 2 Lumps of Ore, 4 points. 80 damage, 60 strength. Classic: 50 damage, 50 strength.
  • Ore Bastard Sword: 2 Lumps of Ore, 6 points. 100 damage, 80 strength. Classic: 60 damage, 50 strength.
  • Heavy Ore Two-Hander: 3 Lumps of Ore, 6 points. 120 damage, 100 strength. Classic: 70 damage, 70 strength.
  • Ore Battle Blade: 3 Lumps of Ore, 8 points. 140 damage, 120 strength. Classic: 75 damage, 65 strength.
  • Heavy Ore Battle Blade: 4 Lumps of Ore, 8 points. 160 damage, 140 strength. Classic: 90 damage, 90 strength.
  • Ore Dragon Slayer: 4 Lumps of Ore + 5 Dragon Blood, 10 points. 160 damage, 140 strength. Classic: 90 damage, 80 strength.
  • Large Ore Dragon Slayer: 5 Lumps of Ore + 5 Dragon Blood, 10 points. 180 damage, 160 strength. Classic: 110 damage, 100 strength.

Collecting Dragon Blood is a trophy skill of its own: without it, a dead dragon gives you none.

Who teaches the ore weapons

Bennet is the main teacher, and only for Mercenaries and Dragon Hunters. Militiamen, Paladins, novices and mages are turned down, and so is anyone who can’t forge a plain sword yet. Before the first lesson he wants 5 Lumps of Ore (he gives 2 back). After that he teaches by chapter:

  • Chapter 2: Ore Longsword and Ore Two-Hander.
  • Chapter 3: Ore Bastard Sword and Heavy Ore Two-Hander.
  • Chapter 4: Ore Battle Blade and Heavy Ore Battle Blade.
  • Chapter 5: both Dragon Slayers.

Two other smiths fill gaps:

  • Dobar, the smith in the castle in the Valley of Mines, teaches the Ore Longsword to anyone who can already forge, whatever the guild – the only ore weapon a Militiaman, Paladin or mage can learn from a teacher.
  • Jan teaches the first four ore weapons (Longsword, Two-Hander, Bastard Sword, Heavy Two-Hander) in chapter 4, to Mercenaries and Dragon Hunters only, as long as the castle gate stays shut.

Spoiler: in chapter 3 Bennet sits in the town’s prison and teaches nothing until you clear his name. In chapter 6 he can join the ship’s crew; aboard he teaches every ore weapon at once, chapter limits gone – but only if he agreed to teach you ore weapons before, which takes the Mercenary or Dragon Hunter route.

Spoiler, chapter 5: a hero who is neither a Paladin nor a Fire Mage and reads the book on the lectern in the monastery’s hidden library learns both Dragon Slayers for free, even without the basic lesson – Militiamen included.

Night of the Raven: Harad’s four blades

In Night of the Raven Harad teaches his apprentice four more one-handers. They need no ore, only Raw Steel, and come one after another once you can forge the plain sword:

  • Fine Sword: 4 learning points. 60 damage, 50 strength, +5% one-handed while held.
  • Fine Longsword: 6 points. 80 damage, 70 strength, +6%.
  • Ruby Blade: 8 points. 100 damage, 90 strength, +7%.
  • El Bastardo: 10 points. 120 damage, 110 strength, +8%.

Classic has swords of the same names, weaker, but no one teaches you to forge them.

This is the smithing line open to every guild. A Paladin or Fire Mage who served Harad can forge 120-damage El Bastardo, where the ore weapons stay closed to them.

Selling your blades to Harad

As his apprentice you can sell Harad what you forge, and he pays more than most traders:

  • Night of the Raven: a third of the weapon’s value – 150 gold for a Sword, 250 for a Fine Sword, 300 for a Fine Longsword, 400 for a Ruby Blade and about 433 for El Bastardo.
  • Classic: the full 100 gold for each Self-forged Sword; he buys no other blades.

Raw Steel is worth 10 gold, so a stack of it and an hour at the anvil turn into a steady income early in the game. He leaves you the blade you have equipped and buys the rest.

Choosing by guild

What a smith can make depends mostly on the guild you join; see the guild guide for the rest of each path:

  • Mercenary and Dragon Hunter: the full ore line from Bennet, including both Dragon Slayers in chapter 5. A two-handed fighter can carry a smith-made weapon from chapter 2 to the end.
  • Militia and Paladin: no ore weapons from Bennet or Jan. Dobar’s Ore Longsword and, in Night of the Raven, Harad’s blades are open; a Militiaman also gets both Dragon Slayers from the library book in chapter 5. Paladins can also buy a Rough Ore Blade from Harad for 2,000 gold (one- or two-handed; 100 or 120 damage in Night of the Raven).
  • Novice and Fire Mage: the same as Paladins without the Rough Ore Blade; few mages need a forge at all.

Learning-point totals and a plan

In Night of the Raven the plain sword is 2 points, the eight ore weapons 56 and Harad’s four blades 28. In Classic the plain sword and all eight ore weapons cost 45. Most players need far less:

  1. Learn the plain sword early from Bennet (30 gold) or as Harad’s apprentice, and sell blades for cash.
  2. Learn only the ore weapons of your style: one-handers or two-handers, not both. Their strength needs climb fast, so plan your strength with the learning-points guide.
  3. Skip the Ore Longsword if you already have the Ore Bastard Sword in reach; each tier replaces the last.
  4. Save 5 Dragon Blood and the ore for one Dragon Slayer in chapter 5; forging both costs 9 Lumps of Ore and 10 Dragon Blood.

In Night of the Raven a non-mercenary with strength to spare gets the most from Harad: Fine Sword through El Bastardo cover the whole game for 28 points.

Changing smithing in a save

If Bennet or Harad died, or your guild locks you out of a weapon you wanted, the Runes & recipes tab of the save editor shows every weapon the hero can forge and switches each one on or off; the first one also gives the smithing talent, as the game does. Use it only on offline single-player saves.

  1. Close the game and copy the whole savegame folder as a backup. Edits are at your own risk.
  2. Open the folder’s files in the editor and go to the Runes & recipes tab.
  3. Under Smithing, switch on the weapons the hero should know, then press Download save.
  4. Copy the downloaded files into the same savegame folder with the game closed and load the save.

You still need Raw Steel, ore and Dragon Blood at the anvil; the Inventory tab can add those.

Sources